← All games

Palace

Three cards in your hand, three face up on the table, three face down that nobody may look at. Get rid of them in that order, and do not be the last player holding cards. Also called Karma. Two to five players.

Swap any of your hand with your face-up row, then start.

You 0
Left 0
Across 0
Right 0
games lost
Left 3 in hand
Across 3 in hand
Right 3 in hand
Stock 16
The pile starts here. Pile 0
0
Burned
Your face-up row
Your hand — 3

Palace: three rows of cards, and nobody wants to be last

Palace is a game with no winner in the usual sense. Everyone starts with nine cards, three of them face down where not even their owner may look, and takes turns playing onto a pile, matching or beating the card on top. Fail to beat it and the whole pile is yours. Players drop out safely as they run out of cards, and the last one still holding any has lost.

Nearly every description of the game stops at the rules, and most leave out what to do when you are stuck on your face-up row, which is where a game is usually decided. They also disagree about how it ends. This page gives the rules as the card-game reference Pagat records them, says where the other versions differ, and answers the strategy questions the only way they can be answered: by giving each habit to one player at a simulated table, thousands of times, against an otherwise identical player.

Blind cards that play
73%
Face-down cards that turned out to be legal when flipped, at four players.
Losers stuck in hand
90%
Losers who still held cards in hand when the game ended, rather than playing from the table.
What attacking costs
+13.2
Points of loss rate given up by throwing your highest card at a player down to their table cards.

Measured on this page's own rules engine, with computer players at a four-player table. Method and full figures are further down.

Where Palace comes from, and why it has so many names

Nobody invented Palace on the record. Pagat traces it as probably Scandinavian or Nordic, perhaps descended from the Swedish game Vändtia ("turn ten") and closely related to the Finnish Paskahousu, and says it spread around the world in the last decades of the twentieth century with young backpackers.

Taught that way, it never settled on a name. It is Palace, Karma, China Hand, Ten-Two Slide, Idiot or, for some, Castle, and in much of the world it goes by a ruder name, which is also what the loser gets called. It is the same game under all of them, give or take a house rule.

How many cards do you deal in Palace?

Nine each, in three rounds of three. First a row of three face down in front of each player, then three face up on top of those, one on each, and then three more as a hand. One pack is enough for two to five players, and whatever is left over goes face down in the middle as the stock: 34 cards at two players, 25 at three, 16 at four and 7 at five. Pagat rates it best with three or more.

PlayersMovesPickups
2646.5
37410.3
48113.0
58715.8
Averages per game across 4,000 simulated games at each size. A move is one play, one pickup or one blind card, by anyone, so a four-player game is about twenty turns each. The pile is burned 5.1 times a game at two players and 7.1 at five.

Should you swap before you play?

Yes, and it is the one decision of the game you get to take at leisure. Before anyone plays, you may swap any of your three hand cards with any of your three face-up cards, as many as you like. On this board, click a hand card and then a row card to exchange them, and press Start playing when you are done.

The conventional advice is to put your best cards on the row, and it holds. Your hand refills from the stock for free for most of the game; your row is what you have left when nothing is coming to help. A player who never swapped lost 32.5% of four-player games against 21.1% for an identical player who did, and 60.6% against 39.4% heads-up.

That includes your twos and tens, which is where people hesitate. Those are the cards that play on anything, so it feels safer to keep them in hand. A player who did lost 29.1% of games against 22.7% over 8,000 games: a card that plays on anything does the most good once you have no choice about what you play next.

Who goes first? Counting from the dealer's left, the first player showing a three on their row. If nobody is, the first player holding a three calls it, and if there is no three about, the same again for the fours and so on up. Going first is no advantage worth worrying about: that player lost 26.1% of four-player games, where an even share is 25%, and the gap is within two standard errors.

How a turn works

  1. Play one or more cards of the same rank from your hand onto the pile. They must be equal to or higher than the card on top. The order runs from three up to ace, and if the pile is empty, anything goes.
  2. Draw back up to three from the stock, if you have fewer than three in hand and the stock has any left. Once it runs out, nobody draws again.
  3. If you can't play, or would rather not, pick up the whole pile into your hand. That is your turn, and the next player starts a new pile with anything.
  4. While you hold any cards in your hand, your hand is all you may play from. Your row waits.
  5. Play passes to the left, skipping anyone who is out.

Three questions come up at every table. Yes, you may play an equal card: a seven goes on a seven. Yes, you may play only some of a set, if you have a reason to, and on this board clicking a card lifts all of that rank, and clicking one again leaves it behind. And yes, you may pick up the pile when you could have played, at least by Pagat's rules. Bicycle's version says you must play if you can. This table allows it, and the strategy section shows why you will rarely want to.

If you have played President, the set-beating will feel familiar, but President's table clears when everybody passes and nobody ever takes the cards. Here there is no passing at all: every failure is paid for in cards. The closer relative is Durak, which shares the pile you are forced to take and the idea that the game exists to find a loser.

What do twos, tens and four of a kind do?

CardWhat it does
TwoGoes on anything. Stays on the pile, and any card may go on top of it.
TenGoes on anything, even an empty pile. The pile is burned out of the game, and you go again.
Four of a kindFour of a rank together on top burns the pile, and you go again. The cards still have to be legal when played.
These are Pagat's rules, and the only special cards on this table. Sevens, threes and eights that do something are house rules, covered at the end.

A burned pile is gone for good, which makes it different from a pile picked up. If you burn it you draw back to three first, then start the new pile with whatever you like. If the card that burned it was your last card anywhere, you are out, and the next player starts instead.

Four of a kind counts cards from different players: it does not matter who laid them, only that four of one rank sit unbroken on top, so playing the fourth seven onto three others is a burn and another turn for you. A two in the middle breaks the run. And it happens more than people expect. At four players, four of a kind burned the pile 3.7 times a game, against 3.0 for tens; heads-up, with fewer cards passing through, it was 1.7 against 3.4.

What happens when your hand runs out?

Your hand only empties once the stock has gone. On your next turn you play from your face-up row, by the same rules, and you may play a set from it if two of the cards match. This is the part most descriptions get wrong by leaving it out: if nothing on your row will go, or you would rather not play it, you pick up the pile and one of your face-up cards goes with it. You choose which.

Stuck on the row: the pile goes up, and takes a card with it

Before

After

Nothing on the row beats the jack, so the pile comes up, and you choose a row card to come with it.

The pile is empty now and the next player starts a new one with anything. You play from your hand until it is empty again, and only then do the two cards left on the row come back into play. The face-down card under the gap has to wait for both of them.

Some households let you pick up and leave the row alone, and Pagat lists that as a variation. It matters less than you might think, and the same is true of the choice itself. Our first run suggested that taking your highest row card rather than your lowest was worth six points of loss rate. Over 1,000 games that looked real, at 2.8 standard errors. Over 4,000 it came out at +0.6 ±1.1, and it was nothing at two, three or five players either. Take whichever you like.

What if a face-down card can't be played?

Once your hand and your row are both gone, you turn over one face-down card each turn, without looking at it first. If it can legally go on the pile, it does, and play moves on. If it can't, the pile and that card come into your hand, the next player starts a new pile, and you are back to playing from your hand until it is empty again before you may turn the next one.

You may never look at a face-down card before it is played, and there is no picking up by choice at this stage: you flip. The last one works the same way, so you only go out if your last card plays. If it doesn't, it goes up with the pile like any other.

Those flips go far better than they feel. Across 42,511 blind cards at simulated four-player tables, 73.3% of them played. A ten or a two always does, and so does an ace, since nothing else ranks above it. Even a three played 42.4% of the time, because you are so often first onto an empty pile or a two.

How often a blind card plays, by rank% of face-down cards that were legal when turned over, four players
Three42.4%
Four44.7%
Five51.8%
Six57.6%
Seven59.2%
Eight65.8%
Nine72.9%
Jack79.0%
Queen85.5%
King93.1%
Ace100%

About 3,300 cards behind each bar, so each carries roughly ±0.9 points. Twos and tens always play and are left off. These are tables of computer players who lead low; a table that keeps the pile higher will see lower figures.

How does Palace end?

When you have no cards left anywhere, you drop out, safe. Everyone else plays on, and the last player left holding cards has lost. There is no score: the loser shuffles and deals the next game, and by tradition pays some forfeit, such as making the tea. The tally above the table on this page counts games lost, and only because you might like to know.

Bicycle and a good many households play it the other way round: the first player out wins and the game stops there. Pagat lists that as a variation. The two feel different, because at a four-player table the first player was out by about move 52 of 81, so more than a third of the traditional game happens after a "winner" would have been declared. The eventual loser finished with 9.2 cards on average, and 90% of them still held cards in hand rather than playing from the table. Losing at Palace is mostly a matter of picking up one pile too many.

Is Palace luck or skill?

You cannot control the face-down cards or what you draw, and it still leans a long way toward skill. Put a player choosing legal moves at random at a table of computer players, and over 1,000 games the random player lost 98.7% of the time and the computer player opposite 0.2%. Much of that edge comes from one unglamorous habit.

Play the lowest card that will go. Almost every clever idea we tried measured worse.

Every habit below was given to one player at a four-player table and measured against an identical player opposite, at the same table, where an even share of losses is 25%. Each was also run at two, three and five players, and none did measurably better than the plain approach at any size.

HabitLostCost
Always play your highest legal card84.9% vs 3.4%+81.5 ±1.7
Play any legal card at random54.6% vs 15.6%+39.0 ±2.3
Break up sets, one card at a time41.0% vs 18.8%+22.3 ±1.2
Take a pile of four or fewer, not spend a two or ten37.6% vs 20.9%+16.7 ±1.2
Throw your highest at a player on their table cards33.9% vs 20.7%+13.2 ±1.2
Never swap before play32.5% vs 21.1%+11.4 ±1.1
Keep twos and tens in hand, off the row29.1% vs 22.7%+6.4 ±0.8
Burn with a ten as soon as you hold one29.2% vs 24.2%+5.0 ±1.2
Take a pile of two or fewer, not spend a two or ten28.4% vs 23.6%+4.8 ±1.1
Play a two ahead of any ordinary card26.9% vs 24.5%+2.4 ±1.1
Burn any pile of six or more26.2% vs 25.2%+1.0 ±1.1
Refuse twos and tens while the stock lasts25.1% vs 24.3%+0.9 ±1.1
Choose your lowest row card to go up with the pile25.1% vs 24.6%+0.6 ±1.1
Lost: the share of games that player lost, against the identical player opposite. Cost: the gap in percentage points, with its standard error. 4,000 games a row, except the top two (about 800 and 1,000) and the twos-and-tens row (8,000). The bottom three sit inside or near their error bars: read them as nothing. A two ahead of an ordinary card, at 2.1 standard errors, is too close to call.
  • Play the lowest card that will go. Low cards only get harder to shed as the pile climbs, and a high card will still be good later. A player who did the reverse lost 84.9% of games against 3.4%. It costs more than playing at random, which cost 39.0.
  • Play the whole set. Two sevens played together is one turn instead of two, and it edges toward a burn. Breaking sets cost 22.3 ±1.2 at four players and 10.8 ±2.6 heads-up.
  • Spend a two rather than take a pile. It feels thrifty to pick up a couple of cards and keep your two, and it isn't. Taking a pile of two or fewer cost 4.8 ±1.1; four or fewer cost 16.7 ±1.2, and 26.2 ±2.1 at three players. Everything you pick up has to be played again before you can get back to your table cards.
  • Hold your tens until nothing else will go. Burning with one the moment you could cost 5.0 ±1.2 at four players and 18.7 ±2.5 heads-up, though almost nothing at five (1.3 ±1.7). There is no need to wait for a big pile, either: burning any pile of six or more was a wash at four players, but cost 7.4 ±2.1 at three and 8.0 ±2.6 at two.
  • Don't go after the player about to get out. Throwing your highest card at someone down to their table cards is the most natural plan in the game, and it was among the costliest things measured: 13.2 ±1.2 at four players, 11.1 ±2.1 at three, 21.3 ±2.5 heads-up, 11.9 ±1.7 at five. You spend a good card to inconvenience one opponent, and what remains in your hand is lower and harder to play.

Common variations

No two tables play the same Palace, and most of the disagreement is over which extra cards have powers. This board plays Pagat's base game, with twos, tens and four of a kind and nothing else.

  • First out wins. Covered above: Bicycle's ending, in which the game stops the moment anyone is out.
  • Two packs. Bicycle shuffles two packs together from three players up.
  • Must play if you can. Also Bicycle's rule, and it removes the choice to take a pile. The measurements above suggest you would rarely want that choice anyway.
  • Seven or lower. The most common extra rule: after a seven, the next player must play a seven or lower, or a two or a ten. Some tables put this on the five, as cardgames.io does. Tried on these same computer players, who were not retuned for it, a game ran the same 80 moves but the average pile picked up fell from 5.2 cards to 1.6, and 4 games in 1,000 never ended.
  • Transparent cards. A three or an eight takes the value of the card beneath it, so the next player must beat what is underneath. Some tables use the seven for this.
  • Reversals and skips. Eights, nines or jacks reverse the direction of play at some tables; others use them to skip the next player.
  • Leave the row alone. Pick up the pile without taking a face-up card with it. Over 1,000 simulated games this changed almost nothing: 81 moves a game against 80.5.
  • Jokers. Two added to let six play. Pagat's version has them played at any time, in any number, reversing direction of play and doing nothing else.
  • A blind deal. Three cards face down, then six to each hand, of which you choose three to lay face up. Nobody sees what you turned away.
  • Stacking. In the version Pagat records as Karma, matching cards can be stacked on one face-down card before play, drawing replacements as you go.
  • Four-card and five-card rows. Finnish players often use four face down and four face up, and one college version recorded by Pagat uses five of each for two or three players.