Hand and Foot: Canasta with a second hand waiting
Hand and Foot is the game North America made out of Canasta. Everybody is dealt two hands. You play the first, the hand, in the ordinary way. The second, the foot, lies face down beside you, and you may not so much as look at it until the hand is gone. Melds grow into piles of seven, piles earn large bonuses, and with five decks on the table there is always something to do on your turn.
If you know Rummy you know the turn: draw, meld, discard. If you know Canasta you know most of the rest, and the differences are that there is more of everything and less to argue about at the discard pile. What you will not find is one agreed set of rules. Hand and Foot has no rulebook and no governing body, only tables that each learned it from someone. So this page plays one named version from start to finish, tells you which, and shows where the versions you may have met differ.
- Turns each in a round
- 17.6
- About 70 turns around the table, and four rounds to a game.
- Of rounds end with someone out
- 55%
- The rest run until the stock cannot supply a draw.
- Piles a side finishes
- 9.4
- Per round: 3.9 clean, 4.8 dirty and 0.7 wild on average.
- Points a round, never taking the pile
- −655
- Measured over 2,000 games against players that do. ±26.
From 12,000 simulated rounds with the computer players in all four seats, and 2,000-game comparisons of one habit at a time.
The objective
Score more points than the other side over four rounds. Points come from the cards you meld and, far more, from completing piles: melds of exactly seven cards. A round ends when a player goes out, which takes five piles of the right kinds and a partner's permission, or when the stock runs dry. Cards left in your hand, and in a foot you never reached, count against you.
How many cards do you deal? It depends who taught you
Thirteen and thirteen, in the version played here. That is Pagat's partnership game for four players, the fullest written account there is, and Pagat itself opens by saying the game has "numerous variations" and "no standard rules". Most other pages deal eleven, and they disagree with each other after that. None of them is wrong. They are describing different tables.
| Rule | Here | Others |
|---|---|---|
| Cards dealt | 13 in the hand, 13 in the foot | 11 and 11, or 11 and 13 |
| Discard pile | Take the top seven cards | The top five, or the whole pile |
| Wild cards | Half as many as naturals: two in a pile of seven | Up to three, or any number fewer than the naturals |
| Red threes | Plus 100 laid out, minus 100 if still held | Minus 300 or minus 500 each |
| To go out | Two clean piles, two dirty and one wild | One clean and one dirty, with no wild pile at all |
The practical advice is the one every Hand and Foot player learns the hard way: agree these five things before the first card is dealt.
Melds, piles, and clean or dirty
A meld is three to seven cards of one rank, from fours up to aces, and it belongs to the partnership, so either of you may add to it. Twos and jokers are wild. A meld may include wild cards as long as it holds at least twice as many natural cards. In practice that is one wild card in a meld of three to five, and two in a meld of six or seven.
At seven cards a meld is complete. It is squared up into a pile and closed, and nothing more can be added. A pile with no wild cards is clean and is topped with a red card. A pile with one or two is dirty and is topped with a black one. You may also meld wild cards on their own, and seven of them make a wild pile. Other tables call piles books or canastas; they are the same thing.
Seven cards make a pile. Which kind depends on the wild cards
A side may have only one unfinished meld of a rank at a time. Once a pile of kings is closed you may start another, and with twenty of every rank in the deck you often will. On the board, select cards and press Meld selected and they go where they belong. To say which meld a wild card is for, select it and click that meld.
Can you pick up the discard pile in Hand and Foot?
Yes, instead of drawing, if three things are true. The top card is not a three. You hold two cards of the same rank as the top card. And you meld those three at once. You then take the top seven cards of the pile, or all of it if it holds fewer, and never more than seven.
If your side has not yet melded this round, the three cards have to reach the opening minimum, with anything else you lay down beside them, and only the top card counts from the pile. The six that come with it do not. A wild card on top can be taken only with two of its own kind: two twos for a two, two jokers for a joker.
Take it when you can. In our games the pile was taken 4.8 times a round, for 6.3 cards on average, and a side that never took it scored 655 points a round fewer (±26) and won 28% of its games. A side told to take it every single time did no better than one that left it alone near the end of a round, when six more cards are a burden (+30 ±27, which is nothing).
When do you pick up your foot?
The moment your hand is empty, and how it empties matters. If you meld every card, you pick the foot up at once and carry on with the same turn, discarding from it. If you meld all but one and discard the last, your turn is over and you begin the next one on your foot.
Players reached the foot on about their ninth turn of a round that lasts seventeen or eighteen. In 29.5% of cases a player never reached it at all, and every card in an unplayed foot is a penalty. Getting onto your foot is half the round.
What are threes for?
Threes are never melded. A red three is laid face up the instant you find one, whether in your hand, in your foot or off the stock, and you draw a card to replace it. Each is worth 100 points to your side at the end of the round. One that is still sitting in a foot nobody picked up costs 100 instead.
A black three has one use. Discard it and the next player may not take the pile. It is worth nothing on the table and costs 5 points if you are caught with it, so each one has to leave your hand through the discard pile, one turn at a time.
How do you go out?
Your side needs two clean piles, two dirty piles and one wild pile. You must be playing your foot. Your partner must have picked up their foot and played at least part of a turn from it. Then you ask, may I go out?, and the answer binds you. On a yes you must go out, melding every card you hold, or every card but one and discarding that. On a no you play on, and while you are on your foot you must keep two cards back when you meld: one to discard and one to hold.
On the board the button does both halves. A yes lays your cards down and ends the round, because after a yes nothing else is legal. Going out earns 100 points, and its real value is that it stops the other side where they stand.
The side that went out outscored the other in 92% of those rounds, by an average of 6,551 points to 4,348.
Somebody went out in 54.7% of rounds (±0.5). When a side did, it outscored the other in 92.1% of those rounds, by an average of 6,551 points to 4,348. Part of that is simply that the side able to go out is the side with more piles. The part that belongs to the act itself we measured separately: a side that never asked, and always played on to the end of the stock, scored 193 points a round fewer (±25) and won 42.5% of its games. Over a whole game the side that went out more often won 80.8% of the time.
The permission, on the other hand, made no difference we could measure. A partner who always says yes, one who refuses when holding more than 50 points, and one who refuses only above 400 all finished within 20 points a round of the standard player, with an error of about 27. By the time a side has five piles, the cards left in a partner's hand are small beside what is on the table.
Scoring
| Item | Points |
|---|---|
| Joker | 50 |
| Two, or ace | 20 |
| Eight up to king | 10 |
| Four up to seven | 5 |
| Clean pile | 500 |
| Dirty pile | 300 |
| Wild pile | 1,500 |
| Red three on the table | 100 |
| Going out | 100 |
| Black three, held | −5 |
| Red three, held | −100 |
The bonuses are the game. Seven sixes are worth 35 points as cards and 500 as a clean pile. In our rounds the winning side averaged 6,679 points and the losing side 4,721, and no side in 12,000 rounds finished one below zero. A game of four rounds ended on average 24,754 to 20,845.
The opening minimum counts card values only. Bonuses and red threes do not help you reach it. It is also less of a barrier than it looks: even in the fourth round, at 150 points, a side's first meld came about two turns in.
Strategy: what three habits cost
Hand and Foot advice is mostly inherited, so we measured it. One side played with a single habit changed, the other played the computer's normal game, over 2,000 games each with the seats alternated. How we make and test our games describes the method.
Points a round lost to the same players without the habit. Errors are ±26, ±25 and ±25. Each is also worth a large swing in games won: 27.7%, 27.5% and 42.5% against an even 50%.
- Take the pile. It is six free cards and a meld, and in a game of matching ranks from five decks, cards are what you are short of.
- Build the wild pile first. It is worth 1,500, three times a clean pile, and you cannot go out without one. Players that spent their wild cards dirtying ordinary melds before the wild pile was finished lost 641 points a round (±25).
- Keep two melds clean. A wild card added to a clean meld can never be taken back, and you need two clean piles to go out.
- Go out when you can. The 100 points are the least of it.
- Shed black threes early, one a turn, when the pile is worth protecting from the player on your left.
The rules we had to decide
A written rule set leaves gaps that a computer cannot. These are ours, each chosen to keep the game moving:
- A game is four rounds and the higher total wins. Level totals are a tie, with no extra round.
- When the stock cannot supply two cards, a player who can take the pile instead must do so, and the round ends at the first player who cannot.
- A red three drawn with the stock empty is not replaced.
- The three cards you take the pile with must fit. They join your side's unfinished meld of that rank if there is room, and otherwise start a new one.
- The two cards you match the pile with are of its rank. A wild card does not stand in for one of them.
Variations, and Hand and Foot for two
The game works for two to six players with one more deck than there are players. Four or six play as partners; two, three or five play for themselves, and tables that play that way set their own going-out requirements. Other common changes are the ones in the table above: eleven-card deals, taking the whole discard pile, and red threes as a flat penalty. Some tables let piles grow past seven cards and call them canastas.
Two relatives are worth knowing by name. Pennies from Heaven is a four-deck relative in which a second hand is picked up after a side makes its first canasta. Triple Play, or Hand, Knee and Foot, adds a third hand and a sixth deck. If Hand and Foot is more table than you want, Gin Rummy is the same family at its smallest: two players, ten cards and no melds on the table at all.
Where Hand and Foot came from
Nobody can say exactly. Canasta is said to have begun in Montevideo, Uruguay, in 1939 and swept North America around 1950. Hand and Foot grew out of it there and was passed on from table to table. The sources that give a date disagree by thirty years, placing it anywhere from the 1950s to the 1980s, and Pagat gives none at all. That is also why there is no standard game. Nobody published one before everybody was already playing their own.